David Rothman (1935-2004) was a pioneer in the sports ratings world, with his rating system being recognized by the NCAA from 1968-2006 as a national championship selector and used as a BCS component from 1999-2002. Here, I produce the ratings and rankings using his system, and I've also preserved his source code from 1990(!) if you'd like to get it and try it yourself.
Files available:
David's method considers only scores. Game locations, dates, and any other information is ignored.
Note 1: Dr. Peter Wolfe has continued to produce David's rankings on his website for many years, and my calculations will differ just slightly -- I have only D1 teams listed here for now, and he includes other divisions.
Note 2: All teams start from scratch - there is no preseason "prior" applied to any team. So these ratings are not meaningful until teams have played 6-7 games, so if you're here early, be VERY warned!
|
Sunday, 18 October commentary: Now that teams have played 6-7 games, the Rothman rankings are in decent shape. If you compare my version of Rothman to Dr. Wolfe's reconstruction, I think he might have modified the formula just a little bit (a few teams float 1-2 places away from where I have them). No issues with the overall integrity of the rankings, though. |
< DAVID ROTHMAN'S COLLEGE FOOTBALL RANKINGS >
BASED ON 1538 GAMES BETWEEN 267 TEAMS, AND NO OTHER INFORMATION
THROUGH GAMES OF SATURDAY 21 NOVEMBER 2026
FOUNDATION FOR THE ANALYSIS OF COMPETITIONS AND TOURNAMENTS
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rank Team W L Rating PCT. RRE Conf.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 Georgia 10 1 100.77 .890 .981 SEC
2 Alabama 9 2 94.02 .806 .964 SEC
3 Tennessee 9 2 92.95 .799 .961 SEC
4 Utah 11 0 91.74 .907 .957 B12
5 Texas 9 2 91.70 .765 .957 SEC
6 Notre Dame 10 1 89.25 .883 .948 FBSIND
7 Miami FL 10 1 86.96 .852 .938 ACC
8 Mississippi 7 4 85.68 .630 .932 SEC
9 Wake Forest 10 1 84.16 .865 .925 ACC
10 Florida 7 4 84.14 .587 .925 SEC
11 LSU 6 5 84.01 .606 .924 SEC
12 Oklahoma 7 4 83.16 .601 .919 SEC
13 Missouri 7 4 82.93 .627 .918 SEC
14 Brigham Young 9 2 82.74 .748 .917 B12
15 Kentucky 7 4 82.59 .584 .916 SEC
16 Texas Tech 10 1 82.20 .831 .914 B12
17 Auburn 7 4 81.53 .592 .911 SEC
18 South Carolina 6 5 81.25 .542 .909 SEC
19 UCLA 10 1 81.23 .849 .909 B10
20 Iowa 9 2 78.32 .775 .891 B10
21 Oregon 8 3 78.19 .703 .890 B10
22 Indiana 9 2 77.86 .780 .888 B10
23 Arizona 8 3 77.64 .712 .887 B12
24 Ohio State 7 4 77.23 .653 .884 B10
25 Louisville 8 3 76.57 .729 .879 ACC
26 Houston 8 3 74.75 .686 .866 B12
27 Mississippi St 5 6 74.35 .457 .864 SEC
28 Arkansas 4 7 73.26 .385 .855 SEC
29 Southern Cal 8 3 72.84 .673 .852 B10
30 Texas A&M 4 7 72.50 .413 .850 SEC
31 Oklahoma St 7 4 72.39 .638 .849 B12
32 Baylor 6 5 71.99 .584 .846 B12
33 Wisconsin 7 4 71.39 .636 .841 B10
34 Nebraska 7 4 70.57 .666 .834 B10
35 Northwestern 6 5 69.19 .579 .823 B10
36 Michigan 6 5 68.96 .522 .821 B10
37 Duke 7 4 68.93 .647 .821 ACC
38 Washington 7 4 68.68 .611 .818 B10
39 SMU 7 4 68.33 .612 .815 ACC
40 Vanderbilt 4 7 68.26 .368 .815 SEC
41 Illinois 6 5 68.11 .533 .813 B10
42 Boise St 9 2 68.05 .771 .813 PAC12
43 Iowa St 5 6 67.66 .460 .810 B12
44 Central Florida 6 5 67.41 .534 .807 B12
45 Arizona St 6 5 67.36 .533 .807 B12
46 Cincinnati 6 5 67.24 .523 .806 B12
47 Minnesota 6 5 67.16 .501 .805 B10
48 Clemson 7 4 67.07 .597 .804 ACC
49 TCU 5 6 66.18 .502 .796 B12
50 North Carolina 5 6 65.67 .486 .792 ACC
51 Penn State 6 5 65.29 .586 .788 B10
52 Pittsburgh 6 5 64.25 .549 .779 ACC
53 West Virginia 5 6 64.19 .461 .778 B12
54 Stanford 6 5 64.03 .490 .776 ACC
55 Virginia 6 5 63.66 .558 .773 ACC
56 Louisiana Tech 9 2 63.63 .766 .773 SUN
57 Florida St 5 6 63.59 .474 .772 ACC
58 Kansas 4 7 63.40 .434 .770 B12
59 Texas-San Antonio 9 2 62.98 .714 .766 AMER
60 Texas St-San Marcos 7 4 62.68 .640 .763 PAC12
61 Colorado 4 7 62.33 .373 .760 B12
62 Virginia Tech 6 5 61.38 .545 .751 ACC
63 Purdue 3 8 61.13 .323 .748 B10
64 North Carolina St 5 6 60.93 .476 .746 ACC
65 Michigan St 3 8 60.70 .323 .744 B10
66 New Mexico 9 2 60.18 .784 .739 MWC
67 Boston College 5 6 59.47 .443 .732 ACC
68 Syracuse 5 6 58.85 .460 .725 ACC
69 Kansas St 4 7 58.64 .419 .723 B12
70 North Texas 7 4 58.38 .618 .720 AMER
71 Maryland 4 7 58.20 .384 .719 B10
72 Tulsa 7 4 58.10 .655 .718 AMER
73 Oregon St 6 5 57.95 .567 .716 PAC12
74 Georgia Tech 3 8 57.31 .310 .709 ACC
75 Memphis 8 3 57.16 .704 .708 AMER
76 Liberty 10 1 57.10 .860 .707 CUSA
77 North Dakota St 9 2 56.98 .784 .706 MWC
78 Air Force 9 2 56.44 .753 .700 MWC
79 Florida Atlantic 7 4 54.98 .601 .685 AMER
80 Toledo 9 2 54.94 .758 .684 MAC
81 Louisiana-Lafayette 8 3 54.88 .699 .683 SUN
82 Western Michigan 8 3 54.71 .689 .682 MAC
83 James Madison 8 3 54.69 .717 .681 SUN
84 Fresno St 6 5 54.61 .573 .681 PAC12
85 San Diego St 6 5 54.09 .495 .675 PAC12
86 Georgia Southern 7 4 53.88 .645 .673 SUN
87 South Dakota St 10 2 52.95 .813 .663 MOVAL
88 UNLV 7 4 52.37 .588 .656 MWC
89 Tulane 6 5 52.04 .490 .652 AMER
90 Army 5 5 51.90 .522 .651 AMER
91 Rutgers 3 8 51.55 .297 .647 B10
92 California 3 8 51.22 .278 .643 ACC
93 Navy 4 6 51.07 .437 .642 AMER
94 Connecticut 6 5 50.99 .575 .641 FBSIND
95 Buffalo 8 3 50.14 .653 .631 MAC
96 Miami OH 7 4 49.49 .611 .624 MAC
97 Montana St 11 1 49.48 .855 .624 SKY
98 Utah St 4 7 49.19 .387 .620 PAC12
99 Alabama-Birmingham 6 5 48.63 .532 .614 AMER
100 East Carolina 7 4 48.36 .580 .611 AMER
101 South Alabama 6 5 48.15 .543 .608 SUN
102 Youngstown St 8 3 47.97 .716 .606 MOVAL
103 Tarleton St 12 0 47.83 .894 .605 UAC
104 South Florida 6 5 47.81 .561 .605 AMER
105 Jacksonville St 8 3 47.43 .670 .600 CUSA
106 Ohio U. 8 3 47.13 .658 .597 MAC
107 Wyoming 7 4 47.09 .587 .596 MWC
108 Stephen F. Austin 10 1 46.88 .867 .594 STHLD
109 South Dakota 9 3 46.36 .712 .588 MOVAL
110 Appalachian St 7 4 45.64 .563 .579 SUN
111 Delaware 6 5 45.25 .555 .575 CUSA
112 Colorado St 3 8 44.61 .293 .567 PAC12
113 Lamar 10 2 44.20 .770 .562 STHLD
114 Nevada 5 6 43.95 .477 .559 MWC
115 Marshall 6 5 43.63 .480 .555 SUN
116 Central Michigan 5 6 43.61 .467 .555 MAC
117 Washington St 2 9 43.49 .258 .554 PAC12
118 North Dakota 8 4 43.48 .667 .554 MOVAL
119 Georgia St 5 6 42.66 .498 .544 SUN
120 Middle Tennessee St 6 5 42.65 .511 .544 CUSA
121 Northern Arizona 9 3 42.46 .679 .541 SKY
122 Coastal Carolina 4 7 41.87 .408 .534 SUN
123 Kennesaw St 5 6 40.87 .483 .522 CUSA
124 San Jose St 5 7 40.31 .432 .515 MWC
125 Arkansas St 4 7 40.22 .395 .514 SUN
126 Rice 2 9 39.93 .258 .511 AMER
127 Florida Int'l 4 7 39.28 .414 .503 CUSA
128 Incarnate Word 8 4 39.19 .686 .502 STHLD
129 Troy 4 7 38.99 .367 .499 SUN
130 Old Dominion 3 8 38.78 .310 .497 SUN
131 Montana 8 4 38.63 .651 .495 SKY
132 Illinois St 8 4 38.35 .641 .491 MOVAL
133 Bowling Green 3 8 38.30 .315 .491 MAC
134 Mercer 10 2 38.18 .745 .489 SOCON
135 Southern Miss 3 8 37.31 .304 .478 SUN
136 Massachusetts 5 6 37.18 .487 .477 MAC
137 Weber St 8 4 37.16 .626 .476 SKY
138 Eastern Michigan 4 7 37.14 .385 .476 MAC
139 Tennessee Tech 9 3 37.08 .705 .475 SOCON
140 Hawai`i 3 8 36.56 .328 .469 MWC
141 Idaho St 7 5 36.22 .610 .465 SKY
142 Harvard 8 2 35.98 .762 .462 IVY
143 Missouri St 4 7 35.53 .395 .456 CUSA
144 Western Kentucky 4 7 35.41 .367 .454 CUSA
145 Austin Peay 8 4 35.12 .675 .451 UAC
146 Temple 2 9 34.95 .278 .449 AMER
147 Abilene Christian 6 6 33.96 .470 .436 UAC
148 Louisiana-Monroe 2 9 33.43 .228 .429 SUN
149 Ball St 3 8 33.03 .302 .424 MAC
150 Idaho 5 7 32.71 .445 .420 SKY
151 North Alabama 7 5 32.44 .569 .417 UAC
152 Kent St 3 8 31.70 .303 .407 MAC
153 Lehigh 10 2 31.53 .772 .405 PATR
154 Monmouth NJ 9 3 31.41 .667 .404 COAS
155 Southern Illinois 5 7 31.41 .420 .404 MOVAL
156 UC-Davis 8 4 30.87 .597 .397 SKY
157 New Mexico St 3 8 30.74 .314 .395 CUSA
158 Southern Utah 6 6 30.30 .521 .390 SKY
159 Western Illinois 8 4 29.97 .664 .385 OVC
160 Western Carolina 7 5 29.74 .563 .382 SOCON
161 Albany NY 8 4 29.50 .659 .379 COAS
162 Chattanooga 7 5 29.19 .585 .375 SOCON
163 UNC-Charlotte 1 10 29.19 .167 .375 AMER
164 Akron 2 9 29.01 .218 .373 MAC
165 East Tennessee St 7 5 28.95 .594 .372 SOCON
166 Yale 6 4 28.88 .603 .371 IVY
167 Northern Iowa 4 7 28.59 .384 .368 MOVAL
168 Campbell 8 4 28.44 .643 .366 COAS
169 Princeton 6 4 28.33 .565 .364 IVY
170 Brown 6 4 28.13 .590 .362 IVY
171 SE Louisiana 5 6 27.91 .439 .359 STHLD
172 Dartmouth 5 5 27.48 .511 .354 IVY
173 West Florida 5 5 26.85 .492 .346 UAC
174 SE Missouri St 7 5 26.52 .568 .341 OVC
175 Bryant 8 4 26.51 .615 .341 COAS
176 Texas-Rio Grande Valley 6 6 26.17 .498 .337 STHLD
177 Colgate 7 5 25.16 .580 .324 PATR
178 Central Arkansas 5 7 25.02 .437 .322 UAC
179 Eastern Kentucky 4 8 24.90 .361 .321 UAC
180 Sacramento St 2 9 24.83 .227 .320 MAC
181 Cornell NY 4 6 24.79 .463 .320 IVY
182 UTEP 1 10 24.70 .142 .318 MWC
183 McNeese St 5 7 24.52 .432 .316 STHLD
184 Portland St 3 9 24.17 .258 .312 SKY
185 Butler 10 2 23.86 .786 .308 PION
186 South Carolina St 10 2 23.80 .789 .307 MEAC
187 Holy Cross 7 5 23.79 .537 .307 PATR
188 Sam Houston St 1 10 23.77 .183 .307 CUSA
189 Pennsylvania 5 5 23.70 .478 .306 IVY
190 Northern Illinois 0 11 23.49 .083 .303 MWC
191 Samford 4 8 23.22 .347 .300 SOCON
192 Villanova 7 5 23.08 .586 .298 PATR
193 Houston Christian 5 7 23.03 .416 .298 STHLD
194 Dayton 10 1 23.00 .835 .297 PION
195 Prairie View A&M 7 5 22.80 .556 .295 SWAC
196 Tennessee-Martin 6 6 22.47 .460 .291 OVC
197 Eastern Washington 3 9 22.39 .289 .290 SKY
198 Murray St 3 9 21.84 .259 .283 MOVAL
199 Northern Colorado 3 9 21.59 .314 .280 SKY
200 Central Conn St 6 5 21.47 .564 .278 NEC
201 Wofford 5 7 21.40 .442 .278 SOCON
202 Cal Poly SLO 4 8 20.40 .346 .266 SKY
203 Columbia 5 5 20.32 .434 .265 IVY
204 Richmond 7 5 20.29 .522 .264 PATR
205 Alabama A&M 9 3 20.20 .747 .263 SWAC
206 Duquesne 6 5 19.99 .541 .261 NEC
207 Lindenwood 5 6 19.47 .457 .254 OVC
208 Stony Brook 6 6 19.32 .508 .253 COAS
209 Eastern Illinois 4 8 19.08 .362 .250 OVC
210 Furman 4 8 18.85 .412 .247 SOCON
211 St Thomas MN 9 3 17.98 .695 .237 PION
212 Rhode Island 5 7 17.78 .434 .235 COAS
213 East Texas A&M 3 9 17.73 .282 .234 STHLD
214 Indiana St 2 10 17.45 .213 .231 MOVAL
215 Jackson St 8 3 17.44 .707 .231 SWAC
216 Arkansas-Pine Bluff 7 4 17.26 .628 .229 SWAC
217 Gardner-Webb 3 9 17.07 .330 .227 OVC
218 Merrimack 5 7 16.87 .372 .225 FCSIND
219 Charleston Southern 4 8 16.51 .382 .221 OVC
220 Nicholls St 4 7 16.08 .329 .216 STHLD
221 New Hampshire 5 7 16.07 .396 .216 COAS
222 LIU 5 7 16.02 .395 .215 NEC
223 North Carolina Central 6 6 15.58 .499 .210 MEAC
224 Sacred Heart 5 6 15.44 .467 .209 FCSIND
225 Utah Tech 1 11 15.44 .166 .209 SKY
226 North Carolina A&T 5 7 15.39 .423 .208 COAS
227 Morgan St 6 6 14.93 .482 .203 MEAC
228 Fordham 4 8 14.82 .352 .202 PATR
229 San Diego 6 5 14.77 .519 .202 PION
230 Alabama St 6 5 14.71 .547 .201 SWAC
231 Lafayette 4 7 14.52 .386 .199 PATR
232 Robert Morris 6 6 14.52 .503 .199 NEC
233 Southern U. 6 5 13.92 .549 .193 SWAC
234 Elon 6 6 13.91 .517 .193 COAS
235 Delaware St 6 6 13.90 .481 .193 MEAC
236 The Citadel 3 9 13.88 .260 .192 SOCON
237 Towson 4 8 13.39 .373 .187 COAS
238 Grambling St 5 5 13.23 .508 .186 SWAC
239 Howard 5 7 13.06 .406 .184 MEAC
240 Tennessee St 4 8 13.02 .325 .183 OVC
241 Alcorn St 6 6 12.64 .513 .180 SWAC
242 William & Mary 4 8 12.33 .343 .177 PATR
243 Georgetown DC 3 7 12.15 .326 .175 PATR
244 Stonehill 4 8 11.77 .360 .171 NEC
245 Norfolk St 5 7 10.84 .485 .162 MEAC
246 Wagner 4 8 8.32 .327 .140 NEC
247 West Georgia 1 11 7.67 .143 .134 UAC
248 Texas Southern 3 8 7.30 .287 .131 SWAC
249 Bethune-Cookman 5 7 7.26 .410 .131 SWAC
250 Valparaiso 5 6 7.16 .476 .130 PION
251 New Haven 3 9 6.65 .270 .126 NEC
252 Maine 1 10 6.65 .179 .126 COAS
253 Florida A&M 4 8 6.16 .343 .122 SWAC
254 Marist 6 6 5.40 .513 .116 PION
255 Mercyhurst 2 10 4.71 .245 .111 NEC
256 Bucknell 1 11 0.88 .177 .086 PATR
257 Drake 3 8 0.20 .312 .082 PION
258 Presbyterian 4 7 0.11 .367 .081 PION
259 Mississippi Valley St 3 9 -3.29 .240 .064 SWAC
260 Chicago St 3 8 -4.59 .296 .058 NEC
261 Hampton 1 11 -5.31 .128 .054 COAS
262 Morehead St 3 9 -7.47 .295 .046 PION
263 Northwestern St 0 11 -8.39 .078 .043 STHLD
264 Davidson 4 8 -9.10 .317 .040 PION
265 Non-Division I 6 62 -12.45 .110 .030 NON-D1
266 Stetson 1 11 -12.96 .157 .029 PION
267 VMI 0 12 -13.56 .060 .027 SOCON
Explanations:
These rankings use the method developed by David Rothman (1935-2004),
founder of the Foundation for the Analysis of Competitions and
Tournaments (FACT). David's work was a part of college football's
Bowl Championship Series for multiple years. His formula considers
only margin of victory for in-season games (past data, date of game,
and location are ignored).
David's original code was written in BASIC in the 1970s -- the copy
that I have is from November 1990 -- and I have rewritten it in
Python to match the original numbers exactly. The only differences
should be in the formatting of the output.
Columns:
Rating: measures a team's strength by balancing their results against
opponent quality. Ratings are iteratively adjusted until the system
reaches a best fit across the entire season. Includes game scores,
but transformed with a logistic function to give diminishing returns
for blowouts or for running up the score.
Pct: the normalized margin-of-victory for a team's games. Effectively
how well did you perform in games, not counting quality of opponent.
Again, though, Rothman's formula is set up so that blowouts do not add
additional information.
RRE: a team's expected win percentage if we were able to play a full
round-robin schedule among all the teams listed. It's functionally
the same as the Rating, just expressed in a different way.
FOUNDATION FOR THE ANALYSIS OF COMPETITIONS AND TOURNAMENTS (FACT)
DAVID ROTHMAN (1935-2004), FOUNDER
FACT Rankings calculated by Cody Kirkpatrick
talismanred.com/ratings
LEAST LIKELY RESULTS OF SEASON 1 St Thomas MN PION 21 Presbyterian PION 55 0.14 2 Dayton PION 22 Drake PION 30 0.18 3 Prairie View A&M SWAC 27 Mississippi Valley St SWAC 28 0.19 4 Furman SOCON 20 Mercer SOCON 13 0.24 5 Massachusetts MAC 37 Rutgers B10 21 0.26 6 Texas Tech B12 24 Cincinnati B12 37 0.27 7 Oklahoma St B12 10 Tulsa AMER 24 0.28 |
I've preserved David's original BASIC source code (last update: 1990!!) if you'd like to get it and try it out yourself. In my testing, it has good results for football, basketball, soccer, and ice hockey, so I imagine it would be useful for just about any sport. (That was the point, when he created it.)
David's rankings were part of college football's Bowl Championship Series from 1999 to 2001, but the next year the BCS managers decided to remove margin of victory from all of the computers that were part of the formula. David refused to change, and that ended his BCS run. If you grab the code and want to do a "politically correct" calculation that does not consider margin of victory, then just change all the scores to 1-0, or 2-0, or 49-0, whatever. Serves the same purpose.
If you download his code (link above), and use it, let me know. I'd love to hear about it.
...I use a version of his code that I developed in Python. Why? So that I can run it in my modern workflow. The numbers reproduce exactly (I've checked in multiple sports), even with over 15,000 games, so I hope that David wouldn't take offense to modernizing the hardware. But I have made sure that I absolutely preserve his math.
