David Rothman (1935-2004) was a pioneer in the sports ratings world, with his rating system being recognized by the NCAA from 1968-2006 as a national championship selector and used as a BCS component from 1999-2002. Here, I produce the ratings and rankings using his system, and I've also preserved his source code from 1990(!) if you'd like to get it and try it yourself.
David's method considers only scores. Game locations, dates, and all other information is ignored. These files are available:
< DAVID ROTHMAN'S MENS HOCKEY RANKINGS >
BASED ON 385 GAMES BETWEEN 64 TEAMS, AND NO OTHER INFORMATION
THROUGH GAMES OF SATURDAY 21 NOVEMBER 2026
FOUNDATION FOR THE ANALYSIS OF COMPETITIONS AND TOURNAMENTS
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rank Team W L T Rating PCT. RRE Conf.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 Dartmouth 6 0 0 54.98 .872 .868 ECAC
2 Augustana 11 0 3 53.25 .771 .782 CCHA
3 Wisconsin 10 1 1 52.83 .788 .757 BIG10
4 Michigan 11 2 0 52.83 .761 .757 BIG10
5 Providence 10 2 0 52.80 .764 .755 HEAST
6 Quinnipiac 9 3 1 52.50 .690 .736 ECAC
7 Minnesota-Duluth 11 3 2 51.94 .697 .698 NCHC
8 Michigan State 7 4 1 51.67 .601 .678 BIG10
9 Western Michigan 8 4 1 51.60 .649 .674 NCHC
10 North Dakota 9 3 1 51.50 .674 .666 NCHC
11 Merrimack 7 4 2 51.27 .572 .649 HEAST
12 Boston University 8 5 1 51.22 .587 .645 HEAST
13 Denver 9 3 2 51.22 .668 .645 NCHC
14 Miami 10 4 0 51.16 .645 .640 NCHC
15 Army 8 2 0 51.02 .713 .629 ATLH
16 Yale 5 2 0 50.88 .637 .619 ECAC
17 Omaha 6 5 1 50.86 .535 .618 NCHC
18 Michigan Tech 9 3 2 50.74 .649 .608 CCHA
19 Northeastern 7 3 0 50.73 .652 .607 HEAST
20 Notre Dame 7 6 1 50.41 .496 .582 BIG10
21 Minnesota 5 4 3 50.24 .512 .568 BIG10
22 Vermont 7 4 2 50.24 .568 .568 HEAST
23 Colorado College 7 6 1 50.21 .545 .566 NCHC
24 Harvard 4 3 0 50.04 .528 .551 ECAC
25 Boston College 6 5 2 50.01 .531 .549 HEAST
26 Maryville 0 0 0 50.00 .000 .548 INDEP
26 Non-Division I 0 0 0 50.00 .000 .548 INDEP
28 New Hampshire 7 6 1 49.74 .520 .527 HEAST
29 Maine 6 7 1 49.56 .487 .512 HEAST
30 Union 7 6 0 49.52 .551 .509 ECAC
31 Connecticut 5 8 1 49.45 .403 .503 HEAST
32 Ohio State 4 8 0 49.39 .392 .498 BIG10
33 Northern Michigan 6 7 1 49.13 .449 .477 CCHA
34 Clarkson 6 5 1 49.04 .533 .470 ECAC
35 St. Thomas 5 6 1 48.98 .470 .465 CCHA
36 Bowling Green 6 8 0 48.97 .457 .464 CCHA
37 Niagara 7 5 2 48.96 .536 .463 ATLH
38 Bentley 6 6 0 48.82 .492 .451 ATLH
39 Massachusetts 5 9 1 48.76 .401 .447 HEAST
40 Minnesota State 4 7 3 48.66 .424 .438 CCHA
41 Robert Morris 6 7 0 48.56 .465 .430 ATLH
42 Princeton 3 4 0 48.35 .447 .413 ECAC
43 St. Cloud State 3 9 1 48.24 .332 .404 NCHC
44 Stonehill 5 6 0 48.23 .459 .403 INDEP
45 Arizona State 5 7 0 48.17 .443 .399 NCHC
46 Alaska 4 8 0 47.98 .354 .384 INDEP
47 Holy Cross 5 10 0 47.97 .369 .383 ATLH
48 Air Force 5 8 0 47.96 .411 .382 ATLH
49 Sacred Heart 6 8 0 47.86 .444 .374 ATLH
50 Cornell 3 5 0 47.84 .420 .373 ECAC
51 Rensselaer 5 8 1 47.52 .430 .348 ECAC
52 Brown 2 5 0 47.52 .341 .347 ECAC
53 Mass.-Lowell 4 10 0 47.44 .357 .342 HEAST
54 Penn State 2 11 1 47.37 .280 .336 BIG10
55 Colgate 4 10 0 47.34 .369 .334 ECAC
56 Lake Superior 4 5 3 47.33 .453 .334 CCHA
57 RIT 3 8 1 47.17 .346 .321 ATLH
58 Bemidji State 2 8 3 47.06 .341 .313 CCHA
59 St. Lawrence 2 4 1 46.89 .383 .302 ECAC
60 Canisius 4 7 2 46.73 .415 .290 ATLH
61 Lindenwood 3 10 1 46.72 .326 .289 INDEP
62 Ferris State 1 8 3 46.64 .275 .284 CCHA
63 Long Island 4 9 0 46.61 .343 .282 INDEP
64 Alaska-Anchorage 1 13 0 45.31 .175 .200 INDEP
Explanations:
These rankings use the method developed by David Rothman (1935-2004),
founder of the Foundation for the Analysis of Competitions and
Tournaments (FACT). David's work was a part of college football's
Bowl Championship Series for multiple years. His formula considers
only margin of victory for in-season games (past data, date of game,
and location are ignored).
David's original code was written in BASIC in the 1970s -- the copy
that I have is from November 1990 -- and I have rewritten it in
Python to match the original numbers exactly. The only differences
should be in the formatting of the output.
Columns:
Rating: measures a team's strength by balancing their results against
opponent quality. Ratings are iteratively adjusted until the system
reaches a best fit across the entire season. Includes game scores,
but transformed with a logistic function to give diminishing returns
for running up the score.
Pct: the normalized margin-of-victory for a team's games. Effectively
how well did you perform in games, not counting quality of opponent.
Again, though, Rothman's formula is set up so that blowouts do not add
additional information.
RRE: a team's expected win percentage if we were able to play a full
round-robin schedule among all the teams listed. It's functionally
the same as the Rating, just expressed in a different way.
FOUNDATION FOR THE ANALYSIS OF COMPETITIONS AND TOURNAMENTS (FACT)
DAVID ROTHMAN (1935-2004), FOUNDER
FACT Rankings calculated by Cody Kirkpatrick
talismanred.com/ratings
Least Likely Results
LEAST LIKELY RESULTS OF SEASON 1 Colgate ECAC 6 Yale ECAC 1 0.31 2 Michigan BIG10 2 Ohio State BIG10 5 0.38 3 Michigan Tech CCHA 1 Ferris State CCHA 2 0.42 4 Northeastern HEAST 0 Stonehill INDEP 4 0.43 5 Army ATLH 0 Air Force ATLH 2 0.46 6 Quinnipiac ECAC 3 Maine HEAST 5 0.48
